Compare Pet Insurance for Dogs and Cats

Eleven insurers side by side: Embrace, Healthy Paws, Trupanion, Figo, Pets Best, ASPCA, Pumpkin, Lemonade, MetLife, Fetch and Odie, all of which cover both dogs and cats. What differs is the deductible (yearly or per condition), how much of a covered bill comes back (50 to 100 percent), the yearly payout limit, whether exam fees are covered, and whether the insurer can pay your vet directly. The table shows each of those for each insurer from its own published terms, reviewed September 21, 2026 (Trupanion's last verified in June 2026). It compares features, not prices, and ranks no one.

Educational content, not insurance or veterinary advice. This page may contain affiliate links; see disclosure below.

Already have a policy?See whether yours holds up in a bad year, free 60-second checkup, no signup.
Run the free pet insurance checkup →

Skip the scroll: get your shortlist

Answer up to three quick questions and we'll float the plans that fit to the top of the table. Skip them and the full comparison is still all yours below.

Side by side

The 11 leading pet insurers, color-coded

The basics that decide what you pay and get back. Tap any heading to sort. This compares features, not a ranking or live quotes, so confirm current terms on each insurer's own site before buying. Affiliate partners are listed first and labeled.

Included / covered Add-on / conditional Not covered

↔ Scroll sideways to see all columns · insurer names stay pinned on the left

InsurerDeductibleReimb.Annual limitExam feesDirect vet payNotableGet a quote
✦ Our partnerBest for dental illness coverSource: getodie.comAnnual70% or 90%$10k or $40kAdd-onBy arrangementCovers periodontal disease if, from age 3, the pet had a cleaning under anesthesia in the prior 13 months; exam fees are an extra-cost optionGet quote →~60 sec, on getodie.com
Embrace
Best for limit choiceSource: embracepetinsurance.com
Annual ($200-$1,000)70-90%$2k - UnlimitedAdd-onNoAccident and illness enrollment up to age 14; orthopedic waiting period varies by stateGet a quoteon embracepetinsurance.com
Healthy Paws
Best for fast claimsSource: healthypawspetinsurance.com
AnnualUp to 90%$5k - UnlimitedNot coveredBy requestNo per-incident or lifetime caps; claims paid in about 2 business days on average; maximum enrollment age varies by stateGet a quoteon healthypawspetinsurance.com
Trupanion
Best for direct vet payTerms last verified June 2026Source: trupanion.com
Per-condition (never resets)90%UnlimitedNot coveredYesPays your vet directly at checkoutGet a quoteon trupanion.com
Figo
Best for highest paybackSource: figopetinsurance.com
AnnualUp to 100%$5k, $10k or UnlimitedAdd-onOn requestUp to 100% back; any licensed vet worldwide; no upper age limitGet a quoteon figopetinsurance.com
Pets Best
Best for deductible choiceSource: petsbest.com
Annual ($100-$1,000)70-90%$5k - UnlimitedAdd-onOptionalNo upper age limit; Vet Direct Pay is optional on every planGet a quoteon petsbest.com
ASPCA
Best for older dogsSource: aspcapetinsurance.com
Annual ($100, $250 or $500)70-90%$2.5k - UnlimitedIncludedNoNo upper age limit; 14-day wait for accidents and illnessesGet a quoteon aspcapetinsurance.com
Pumpkin
Best for dental illnessSource: pumpkin.care
Annual80% or 90%$5k - UnlimitedIncludedOn requestCovers dental illness; no upper age limitGet a quoteon pumpkin.care
Lemonade
Best for app claimsSource: lemonade.com
Annual ($100-$750)70-90%$5k - $100kAdd-onNoLemonade says approved claims can pay in minutes; sold in 42 states plus DCGet a quoteon lemonade.com
MetLife
Best for no age limitSource: metlifepetinsurance.com
Annual ($0-$2,500)50-90%$500 - UnlimitedIncludedNoNo upper age limit; may honor prior-covered conditions when you switch through an employer planGet a quoteon metlifepetinsurance.com
Fetch
Best for broad coverageSource: fetchpet.com
Annual70-90%$5k - UnlimitedIncludedNoBroad single policy: dental, and behavioral therapy up to $1,000 a yearGet a quoteon fetchpet.com

Reviewed September 21, 2026 against each insurer's published terms; the desk re-checks them every quarter. Trupanion's site could not be read at this re-check, so its row shows the terms as last verified in June 2026. Always confirm current terms on the insurer's own site before buying.

✦ Affiliate partner

Why Odie is our first insurance partner

Odie is the one insurer we have a live link with today. Here is what its own help center and sample policy say, the strengths and the limits.

Dental illness coveredPeriodontal disease is covered, with one condition: from age 3, the pet needs a cleaning under anesthesia in the prior 13 months.
Two annual limits$10,000 or $40,000 a year, with no separate cap per incident.
70% or 90% backYou choose the reimbursement rate when you get a quote.

Worth knowing: Exam fees are an optional benefit at extra cost, and Odie pays the vet directly only where it has an arrangement with that clinic. If unlimited cover or paying the vet directly is your priority, compare it against those options above. (Odie sample policy, Odie help center)

Get an Odie quote → Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you; it never changes the comparison above.
Read a policy like a pro

The 6 things that actually differ

Deductible & its type

Most use an annual deductible (paid once a year). A few (e.g. Trupanion) use a per-condition deductible that never resets, cheaper for one chronic illness, pricier across several.

Reimbursement %

What you get back after the deductible, usually 70/80/90% (a couple reach 100%) (see the table above). Higher percentage means a higher premium but more back when you claim.

Annual limit

The yearly payout cap, from a few thousand dollars to unlimited. A low cap is where people get burned by a surgery or cancer year.

Exam fees

The charge for the visit itself. Some insurers include it; others exclude it or make it an add-on. On a big emergency bill, it adds up fast.

Waiting periods

Roughly 14 days for illness, a few days for accidents, and 30 days to 6 months for orthopedic conditions (see the pet insurance comparison chart). Anything during the wait isn't covered.

Pre-existing conditions

Anything showing symptoms or diagnosed before coverage starts is typically never covered. That's why you insure early, and why switching insurers can cost you coverage.

Don't overlook: how you get paid

Most insurers reimburse you after you pay the vet and file a claim. A few offer direct vet pay, where the insurer pays the clinic at checkout so you only cover your share, a big deal in a $5,000 emergency. Trupanion leads here; Pets Best and Healthy Paws offer it conditionally.

How to use this comparison

  1. Pick your must-haves first. Budget + disaster protection → unlimited limit, higher deductible. Worried about fronting bills → direct vet pay. Older dog → no upper age limit.
  2. Get 3 quotes at the same settings (e.g. $500 deductible, 80% reimbursement, $5,000 limit) so it's apples to apples.
  3. Read the exclusions, not just the coverage. Exam fees, dental illness, and prescription food are common gaps.
  4. Insure early, while your pet is young and healthy and nothing is "pre-existing" yet.
The basics, answered

Pet insurance FAQ

Straight answers to the questions owners actually search, so you can read any policy with confidence.

Go deeper

Insurance guides by breed and condition

How coverage fits specific breeds and the conditions owners ask about most.

Already have a policy?

Most owners can't say what their plan really covers until they need it. Our free 60-second checkup walks you through the five numbers that decide whether yours holds up in a bad year, no signup, no uploads.

Run the free pet insurance checkup →

Disclosure: This site may earn a commission from insurance or product links, at no extra cost to you, and it never changes what we write. Insurer details are gathered from public sources and may change; this is educational information, not advice. Confirm current terms directly with each insurer. About